Menu

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more ›

Best Canned Tomatoes

Discover premium canned tomatoes, including whole peeled San Marzano-style, crushed, and organic diced varieties from top brands like Cento and Muir Glen, perfect for sauces, soups, and stews.

35 products 15 subcategories

Select a Product

Click on a product from the list to view its details.

PRIME

AmericanReviews.org score rating is a scoring system developed by our experts. The score is from 0 to 10 based on the data collected by the AmericanReviews.org tool. This score doesn't impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. We encourage you to write a review of your experiences with these products. Learn more »
Last update on . Affiliate links, prices, images, product titles, and highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Pros

Cons

Key Features

User Reviews

Your review will be visible after approval.

Loading reviews...
Jersey Fresh Fattoria Fresca Crushed Tomatoes 28oz Pack of 12 - Pure NJ Tomatoes No Citric Acid or Additives

Jersey Fresh Fattoria Fresca Crushed Tomatoes are pure, kettle-cooked New Jersey tomatoes with no citric acid, sugar, water, or concentrate. Home cooks crafting authentic sauces, stews, and pizzas should buy this pack for its fresh-like intense flavor.

  • Pure NJ tomatoes packed at peak ripeness for burst-of-fresh flavor
  • Zero additives like citric acid, sugar, water, or concentrate for clean taste
  • Kettle-cooked old-world style enhances natural sweetness and depth
  • Rich in antioxidants, vitamins A, C, and lycopene for health benefits
  • Versatile base for pasta sauces, chili, stews, pizza, and dips

Exceptional fresh-like flavor and low acidity. Single ingredient: just high-quality tomatoes. Intense taste develops quickly in recipes.

Some shipments arrive dented or leaking. High seed content may bother some users.

Muir Glen Organic Fire Roasted Diced Tomatoes 28 oz Can - USDA Organic Non-GMO Gluten-Free Pantry Staple

Muir Glen Organic Diced Fire Roasted Canned Tomatoes are 28 oz cans of California-grown, peak-harvested tomatoes with smoky sweet flavor. Ideal for home cooks wanting clean, no-sugar-added ingredients for sauces, salsas and chili.

  • Instant smoky flavor boost for pasta sauces and salsas
  • USDA Certified Organic from California rich soil
  • Non-GMO Project Verified for pure clean eating
  • Gluten-free versatile pantry essential
  • Quick shortcut to homemade-tasting recipes

Rich smoky sweet taste praised in reviews. No added sugars or unclean ingredients. Exceptional freshness and flavor depth.

Higher cost than conventional tomatoes. Not widely stocked in all local stores. Large can best for family-sized recipes.

Colavita Italian Diced Tomatoes Non-GMO 13.76oz Tetra Recart Pack of 16 - Authentic Fresh Flavor

Colavita Recart Diced Tomatoes are premium Non-GMO Italian tomatoes diced into chunks, packed in sustainable Tetra Recart cartons that preserve freshness without metallic taste. Buy them if you want authentic ingredients for chunky sauces, bakes, bruschetta, or salads.

  • Authentic Po Valley Italian tomatoes deliver ripe, juicy flavor in every bite
  • Tetra Recart packaging locks in freshness with no metallic or paper taste
  • Chunky diced texture perfect for hearty sauces, bakes, bruschetta, and salads
  • Non-GMO and no salt added for clean, customizable cooking
  • Resealable cartons save space and maintain quality for multiple uses

Superior freshness and natural taste from premium Italian sourcing. Eco-friendly Tetra Pak eliminates can taste in recipes. Chunky cut retains tomato texture for robust dishes.

No added salt requires personal seasoning adjustments. Large 16-pack suits frequent cooks over occasional users. Tetra Recart format may feel unfamiliar at first.

Organic Petite Diced Tomatoes with Jalapeno & Cilantro, 365 by Whole Foods Market, 10 oz Can - Zesty Salsa Essential

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Petite Diced Tomatoes with Jalapeno & Cilantro come in a convenient 10 oz can, offering bold spicy flavor from jalapeno and fresh cilantro notes. Home cooks making salsa, chili, or sauces will love the organic quality and petite dice for perfect texture.

  • Bold zesty kick from jalapeno and cilantro elevates salsas and sauces instantly
  • Petite dice ensures consistent texture for easy mixing in recipes
  • Organic certification means no harmful pesticides or banned ingredients
  • Versatile for chili, marinara, pizza sauce, toppings on eggs or salads
  • Supports sustainable farming with Whole Foods Market quality standards

Intense flavorful blend perfect for homemade salsa. Organic and thoughtfully sourced ingredients. Highly versatile across multiple dishes.

Can be slightly watery compared to competitors. Less intense flavor than some popular brands like Rotel. Higher price point for the organic premium.

365 by Whole Foods Market Diced Tomatoes 28 oz - BPA-Free, Flavorful Pantry Staple for Soups, Chilis & Salsas

365 by Whole Foods Market Diced Tomatoes come in a 28-ounce can with real flavor and no harmful additives like hydrogenated fats. Home cooks building a quality pantry for soups, chilis, and salsas will appreciate this reliable, affordable staple.

  • Burst with fresh tomato flavor to elevate soups, chilis, and sauces
  • BPA-free cans ensure safer, healthier meal prep
  • Meets strict Whole Foods quality standards without 300+ banned ingredients
  • Generous 28-ounce size perfect for family recipes and bulk cooking
  • Affordable price delivers premium taste without compromise

Exceptional flavor praised in reviews for tasting better than competitors. BPA-free packaging for peace of mind. High-quality ingredients aligned with Whole Foods standards.

Cans may arrive dented from shipping. Not certified organic. Lacks detailed nutritional specs in listing.

San Merican Tomato Crushed Canned Tomatoes 28oz Pack of 6 USA Grown - Premium Fresh Flavor for Sauces

San Merican Tomato crushed canned tomatoes are USA-grown in 28-ounce cans sold in packs of six. They deliver fresh, superior taste praised in reviews for homemade sauces and pasta, ideal for flavor-focused home cooks.

  • Fresh summer-like tomato taste elevates any sauce
  • USA grown ensures premium quality and freshness
  • Ideal crushed consistency for easy pasta and lasagna recipes
  • Recommended by America's Test Kitchen for top performance
  • Versatile base for authentic Italian dishes

Exceptional fresh flavor outperforms other brands. Perfect for homemade pasta sauces and lasagna. High customer satisfaction for taste quality.

Some cans arrive dented from shipping. Higher price compared to basic brands. One review noted thinner consistency.

Muir Glen Organic Diced Tomatoes 14.5 oz - USDA Certified Organic, Non-GMO, Gluten-Free Pantry Staple for Pasta & Chili

Muir Glen Organic Diced Tomatoes are firm, juicy, and vibrant red canned tomatoes grown in California fields at peak ripeness. Home cooks making pasta, chili, salsas, or casseroles will appreciate their fresh taste and high quality over cheaper brands.

  • Unlock fresh, vine-ripened flavor in every recipe with California-grown organic tomatoes
  • Lightly seasoned with sea salt for enhanced taste without overpowering your dishes
  • Versatile pantry essential perfect for lasagna, chili, bruschetta, and homemade salsas
  • USDA Certified Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified for clean, wholesome eating
  • Gluten-free and harvested at peak freshness to maintain firmness and color

Firm, red diced pieces that taste like fresh tomatoes. Rich flavor that stands out in Italian recipes, chili, and pizza sauces. Consistent high quality as a reliable pantry staple.

Cans often arrive dented from shipping or warehouse handling. Premium organic quality comes at a higher cost than conventional options.

Sclafani Crushed Tomatoes 28oz Pack of 12 - Pure Vine-Ripened Flavor No Additives

Sclafani Crushed Tomatoes are crafted from fresh vine-ripened whole tomatoes with just a pinch of salt and no added puree, paste, or citric acid for the truest tomato flavor. Buy this bulk pack of twelve 28-ounce cans if you need premium canned tomatoes for authentic Italian sauces and everyday cooking.

  • Experience the purest tomato taste from fresh vine-ripened whole tomatoes
  • No added puree, paste, or citric acid for clean, natural flavor
  • Just a pinch of salt enhances freshness without overpowering
  • Convenient 28-ounce cans in a bulk pack of 12 for frequent cooks
  • Top-ranked in canned crushed tomatoes for reliable quality

Authentic, fresh tomato flavor without artificial additives. Minimal ingredients for healthier cooking options. Bulk pack offers great value for home chefs and restaurants.

Bulk pack of 12 may overwhelm small households. Thinner consistency without added paste requires recipe adjustments. Large dimensions demand ample pantry storage space.

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Fire Roasted Crushed Tomatoes 28 oz - Fresh Flavor for Sauces Soups Stews

Organic fire-roasted crushed tomatoes from 365 by Whole Foods Market offer fresh, rich flavor and ideal texture for pasta sauces, soups, and stews. Home cooks wanting natural, high-quality pantry staples for family meals should buy this.

  • Intense fire-roasted flavor elevates homemade sauces and soups
  • Smooth texture with chunks mimics fresh homemade tomatoes
  • Organic certification ensures pure, natural ingredients without additives
  • Generous 28 oz size perfect for family recipes and meal prep
  • Versatile for pasta, chili, stews, and slow cooker dishes

Fresh, rich taste that blends well with herbs and spices. Not watery, holds up great in slow cookers and sauces. Organic and thoughtfully sourced for clean eating.

Slightly acidic, may need sugar or cream to balance. Some cans have lids that do not open fully.

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Crushed Tomatoes with Basil, 28 oz - Fresh Flavor for Sauces, Soups & Chili

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Crushed Tomatoes with Basil is a 28-ounce can of USDA organic tomatoes infused with basil for rich, fresh flavor. Home cooks seeking clean-ingredient pantry staples for pasta sauces, chilis, and soups will love its consistent quality and vibrant taste.

  • Rich, fresh tomato flavor mimics homemade sauces
  • Basil infusion adds instant herbaceous depth
  • USDA organic with no artificial additives or banned ingredients
  • Versatile base for marinara, chili, soups, and stews
  • Consistent texture perfect for smooth blending

Exceptional fresh taste praised in recipes. Clean organic ingredients build family trust. Well-balanced flavor needs minimal seasoning.

Basil flavor can overpower subtle dishes. Large can size suits families over singles. Some prefer other brands for specific pasta recipes.

Welcome to our Canned Tomatoes category, your go-to source for high-quality, pantry-essential tomatoes that elevate everyday cooking. Whether you're crafting authentic Italian pasta sauces, hearty chilis, or fresh salsas, these whole peeled, crushed, diced, and fire-roasted options from trusted brands deliver consistent flavor and convenience without compromising on taste or nutrition.

Understanding Canned Tomatoes

Canned tomatoes are a staple in kitchens worldwide, offering year-round access to ripe, flavorful tomatoes preserved at their peak. Unlike fresh tomatoes, which can be seasonal and inconsistent, canned varieties provide reliable texture and taste, making them ideal for home cooks and professional chefs alike. This category features premium products like San Marzano-style whole peeled tomatoes, organic crushed tomatoes, and fire-roasted diced options, all packed in convenient 14.5 oz to 28 oz sizes.

Types of Canned Tomatoes Available

Choosing the right type depends on your recipe. Here's a breakdown:

  • Whole Peeled Tomatoes: Intact tomatoes in thick puree, perfect for sauces where you want control over chopping. Look for San Marzano varieties for their sweet, low-acidity profile.
  • Crushed Tomatoes: Pre-broken down for quick simmering in soups, stews, or marinara. They offer a smooth base with natural thickness.
  • Diced Tomatoes: Uniformly cut for salsas, casseroles, or chili. Fire-roasted versions add smoky depth.

Many in this selection are organic and imported, ensuring minimal additives and maximum authenticity. For broader pantry options, explore our Pantry Staples category.

Top Products and Brands

Standouts include the SMT San Merican Tomato Whole Peeled Tomatoes and Crushed Tomatoes, known for their robust flavor mimicking traditional Italian imports. Cento excels with their Organic San Marzano Peeled Tomatoes and Crushed Tomatoes, prized for basil-infused puree and certified quality—check out more at the Cento brand page or their full Cento Canned Tomatoes lineup.

Muir Glen offers organic diced fire-roasted and regular diced tomatoes, delivering bold taste with clean ingredients. Dive deeper into Muir Glen selections for sustainable farming focus. SANMERICANTOMATO provides value-packed options like their whole peeled cans, ideal for bulk cooking—see all at SANMERICANTOMATO.

What to Look for When Shopping Canned Tomatoes

Prioritize these key features for the best results:

  • Variety and Origin: San Marzano tomatoes from Italy offer superior sweetness and meaty texture over generic plum tomatoes.
  • Organic Certification: Ensures no pesticides, appealing for health-conscious shoppers.
  • Ingredients: Opt for products with just tomatoes, puree, basil, or salt—no citric acid or thickeners if purity matters.
  • Pack Size and Pack Options: Singles for occasional use or multi-packs like Cento's 6-pack for frequent cooks.
  • Texture and Consistency: Firmer for sauces, softer crushed for immediate use.

Back up to our Tomatoes parent category for fresh alternatives, or browse Vegetables for more canned produce.

Common Uses for Canned Tomatoes

Versatile and shelf-stable, these tomatoes shine in diverse dishes:

  • Pasta sauces and ragùs, where whole peeled build complex flavors.
  • Chilis, stews, and braises using crushed for body.
  • Salsas, tacos, and salads with diced fire-roasted for smokiness.
  • Soups, curries, and casseroles for quick flavor bases.
  • Baked goods like pizza or shakshuka.

They save time compared to roasting fresh tomatoes and retain vitamins like lycopene. For related canned goods, visit Canned, Jarred & Packaged Foods.

Storage and Handling Tips

Store unopened cans in a cool, dry pantry. Once opened, transfer leftovers to airtight containers and refrigerate for up to 5 days, or freeze for months. Always check for dents or bulges before use.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes San Marzano canned tomatoes special?

San Marzano tomatoes, like those from Cento, grow in volcanic soil near Mount Vesuvius, yielding sweeter, less acidic fruit with thicker flesh—ideal for premium sauces.

Whole peeled vs. crushed: Which is better for pasta sauce?

Whole peeled allows customization and fresher taste; crushed is faster for thick, ready sauces. Both work well, depending on time.

Are organic canned tomatoes worth it?

Yes, brands like Muir Glen avoid synthetic pesticides, offering cleaner taste and nutrition without sacrificing flavor.

How do I choose between brands like Cento and Muir Glen?

Cento leans Italian authentic with San Marzano; Muir Glen emphasizes U.S. organic. Sample based on recipe needs.

Can I use canned tomatoes in place of fresh?

Absolutely, especially off-season. Drain excess liquid and adjust seasoning for best results.